An external test answers whether someone can get in. An internal test answers what happens after they do. Since phishing and stolen credentials are common ways in, a strong perimeter alone tells you little about your real exposure. Both are forms of network penetration testing. For 2027 scoping, distinguish internet-exposed assets from the paths available after a compromised user or device gains access. Include cloud identity and remote access where relevant, with written authorisation and clear testing boundaries.
Internal penetration testing vs External penetration testing at a glance
| Topic | Internal penetration testing | External penetration testing |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | Anywhere on the internet | Inside the network, usually with a normal user account |
| Simulates | An outside attacker | A phished employee, stolen laptop or insider |
| Targets | Websites, VPNs, email, DNS and cloud services | Active Directory, file shares, internal apps and servers |
| Typical findings | Unpatched services, exposed admin panels, weak authentication | Privilege escalation, poor segmentation, shared passwords |
| Main question | Can someone get in? | How far could they go? |
| Access needed | None, or a list of targets | VPN or a device on the network |
| PCI DSS | Required at least yearly | Required at least yearly |
Choose Internal penetration testing if
- You have public-facing apps or services.
- You have never tested your perimeter.
- A buyer asks for an external test report.
Choose External penetration testing if
- You have many staff, offices or a Windows domain.
- You want to measure the damage from a phishing attack.
- You handle cardholder data and need to test segmentation.
Do you need both?
Most companies benefit from both each year, and it is often cheaper to scope them together. Purely cloud-native SaaS companies with no office network may put more effort into external, application and cloud configuration testing instead. See the types of VAPT testing to decide your scope.
What Avantcert charges
These are Avantcert reference package prices in US dollars. The package includes the initial independent assessment where required for the agreed scope.
| Framework | 5–50 staff | 51–200 staff | 201–500 staff | Time, up to |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VAPT | $1,000 | $5,500 | $10,000 | 30 days |
Internal penetration testing vs External penetration testing: common questions
Which is more important, internal or external testing?
For most companies, start with external testing because it is exposed to everyone. But internal testing often finds the more serious problems, since a single phished account can lead to full domain control when networks are flat.
Does PCI DSS require internal and external tests?
Yes. PCI DSS requires both internal and external penetration tests at least every 12 months and after significant changes, and it also requires segmentation testing if you use segmentation to reduce scope.
Can internal testing be done remotely?
Yes. Most internal tests now use a VPN connection or a small device shipped to your office. On-site testing is usually needed only when wireless or physical access is part of the agreed scope.
What is an assumed breach test?
It is an internal test that starts from a compromised user account rather than trying to break in first. It saves testing time and reflects how many real incidents begin, with stolen credentials.
Read next
- Penetration testing services
- Web application penetration testing
- VAPT for ISO 27001 and SOC 2
- All comparisons